Task Force Blog

Blog

Chinese Merger Tactics Show Importance of Incorporation Transparency

August 3, 2011

By Dan Hennessey

Daniel Hennessey, an international affairs and geography major at the George Washington University, is an outreach and communications intern at Global Financial Integrity in Washington, DC.

Martin Kenny/Flickr*

Reuters recently released the second feature in Shell Games, a series “exploring the extent and impact of corporate secrecy in the United States.” The first special report in the series, “A little house of secrets on the Great Plains” dealt with shell companies established in Wyoming, generally recognized as a secrecy jurisdiction, and how some have been used to hide illict assets .

The newest report, “China’s shortcut to Wall Street” details how the reverse-merger process has allowed many Chinese companies to become publicly traded in the U.S., while bypassing many regulatory controls.  The article details the process:

Brokers acquire shells, often domiciled in a secrecy-friendly state such as Delaware, Utah or Nevada. The broker then sells the U.S. shell to an operating company seeking to trade on a U.S. exchange—a transaction which, unlike an initial public offering, isn’t overseen by regulators.

The acquiring firm thus becomes a publicly-traded company, with access to U.S. investors – but without the time, expense and scrutiny of a traditional initial public offering. Companies are incorporated under state rather than federal law, and so the federal overseer of stock flotations, the Securities and Exchange Commission, doesn’t as a matter of course review reverse mergers until after the deal is done.

These issues are further complicated as many Chinese companies are actually incorporated in the British Virgin Islands or other secrecy jurisdictions, making tracing the details of financial transactions and taking action against companies more difficult.

Reverse-mergers are not a recent development, but have taken off dramatically of late, especially as Chinese corporations began adopting the practice, with over 400 doing so in recent years.  With well over 1,000 publicly traded shell companies—generally with little or no actual assets in existence—the potential opportunities to exploit this unregulated backdoor to public trading abound, though it has become far less frequent since the process became well publicized.  Since then, stock values have fallen, as accounting irregularities have become apparent and as short-sellers set these companies in their sights.

The bi-partisan Incorporation Transparency and Law Enforcement Act of 2011introduced yesterday by Senators Carl Levin (D-MI) and Chuck Grassley (R-IA), would aim to improve transparency in the incorporation process.  Among its provisions is an element requiring states to determine and report the beneficial owners of corporations incorporated in their states.  Federal agencies will then be able to obtain that information for investigations with subpoenas, uncovering some of the layers of secrecy used to hide illicit enterprises.

GFI’s Heather Lowe spoke about the important role increased information about shell companies will play for law enforcement and financial oversight agencies:

The U.S. financial system is a playground for corrupt, criminal, tax evading individuals from other countries,” said Ms. Lowe. “It is far too easy to gain access to financial services in the U.S. through anonymous U.S. corporations, while it is far too difficult for law enforcement groups to figure out who is really behind those corporations.

You can read Senator Levin’s release on the bill here, and find out more about beneficial ownership issues from the Task Force.

Image license: Some rights reserved by coofdy

Share

Disclaimer: Unless specifically stated to be the views of the Task Force, the opinions expressed on this blog are solely the opinions of the individual blogger and are not necessarily those of the Task Force on Financial Integrity & Economic Development.

Latest Press Releases

GFI’s Tom Cardamone to Testify before Senate Committee Regarding the Global Security Implications of Poaching

Global Financial Integrity · May 23, 2012

WASHINGTON, DC – Global Financial Integrity (GFI) Managing Director Tom Cardamone will testify tomorrow before the full U.S. Senate Committee on ...

FTSE Giants Face Tough Questions on Tax and Financial Secrecy at AGMs This Year

Christian Aid · May 22, 2012

BRUSSELS - Tax is joining high pay as an issue at FTSE100 companies’ AGMs this year, with Boards facing tough questions about ...

GFI Calls on G8 to Tackle Illicit Financial Flows at Camp David Summit

Global Financial Integrity · May 17, 2012

WASHINGTON, DC – Global Financial Integrity (GFI) today called on leaders of the G8 to concretely tackle the issue of illicit financial ...