Task Force Blog

Blog

The Isle of Man has now lost all the subsidy I said it enjoyed – my campaign on this issue is over

July 12, 2011

By Richard Murphy

Richard Murphy is a founder of the Tax Justice Network and director of Tax Research LLP. An expert on tax policy, he writes a daily blog which provides regular news on his activities and opinions at www.taxresearch.org.uk/Blog/

Andy Stephenson/Wikimedia Commons

When I first looked at the subsidy the UK gave to the Isle of Man through its VAT sharing agreement I came to the conclusion that the sum involved exceeded £200 million a year.

In 2009 the UK government removed £140 million of that subsidy a year.

Yesterday they announced intention to increase the withdrawal if subsidy to a total of £215 million a year – very close to the sum I first calculated.

Justice has been done, I am pleased to say.  A subsidy to an island that did not need it so that it could undermine the effectiveness of the operation of the UK’s tax system has been removed. This move does not in any way impact on the fiscal status of the Isle of Man but it does require that it raise its own revenue to pay for its own government in future if it insists on pursuing its wholly unacceptable taxation policies.

I am pleased.

I am also pleased to have been credited (by the Isle of Man government) with playing a part in this.

And I am pleased that, yet again, my estimates have been proven remarkably accurate.

On which basis I continue to forecast that the resulting economic crisis for the Isle of Man will force it, like Jersey and Guernsey to radically overhaul their economic policies and their tax haven status sooner rather than later.

And that’s the best news of all for the UK, our economy and in due course for these islands and the people who really want to live in them rather than to abuse them.

Share

Disclaimer: Unless specifically stated to be the views of the Task Force, the opinions expressed on this blog are solely the opinions of the individual blogger and are not necessarily those of the Task Force on Financial Integrity & Economic Development.

  • Janice Bailey

    Then move on to Scotland and Wales: spending per head from UK taxpayers in these countries is way above that of England. Scotland can then discriminate against English students to provide subsidised education for Scottish ( plus the rest of the EU) students. Double whammy as English students(and often their parents) therefor have to pay towards their own education and also that of others. Cannot see how this doesn’t get greater publicity as it is grossly unfair.

    • Mike Dimmick

      Scotland has reserve powers to vary the income tax rate applied to Scottish residents by up to 3p above or below the basic rate set by Westminster. They have not yet made use of this power. The Welsh Assembly does not have this power.

      Scotland does get a lot of the North Sea oil revenue, and this is a large part of how they are able to pay for tuition fees.

      Neither Scotland nor Wales is a tax haven – there are no tax benefits directly attributable to basing a company in Scotland or Wales, excepting that large manufacturers trying to decide on a site in Europe will game governments off against each other, to offer bigger and better tax breaks. A condition of the tax breaks will be siting it in a deprived area or marginal constituency.

Latest Press Releases

GFI’s Tom Cardamone to Testify before Senate Committee Regarding the Global Security Implications of Poaching

Global Financial Integrity · May 23, 2012

WASHINGTON, DC – Global Financial Integrity (GFI) Managing Director Tom Cardamone will testify tomorrow before the full U.S. Senate Committee on ...

FTSE Giants Face Tough Questions on Tax and Financial Secrecy at AGMs This Year

Christian Aid · May 22, 2012

BRUSSELS - Tax is joining high pay as an issue at FTSE100 companies’ AGMs this year, with Boards facing tough questions about ...

GFI Calls on G8 to Tackle Illicit Financial Flows at Camp David Summit

Global Financial Integrity · May 17, 2012

WASHINGTON, DC – Global Financial Integrity (GFI) today called on leaders of the G8 to concretely tackle the issue of illicit financial ...