Task Force Blog

Blog

When Will Cayman Learn?

February 22, 2011

By Richard Murphy

Richard Murphy is a founder of the Tax Justice Network and director of Tax Research LLP. An expert on tax policy, he writes a daily blog which provides regular news on his activities and opinions at www.taxresearch.org.uk/Blog/

I note the new Chair of Cayman Finance seems determined to continue in the tradition of his predecessor.

Interim Chairman Roy McTaggart , who recently succeeded Anthony Travers OBE, has sent a letter to Ronnie Campbell, MP because  he referred to the Cayman Islands as a tax haven during a debate in the House of Commons last week. McTaggart said, according to Cayman News Service, that:

Cayman is a fully transparent jurisdiction and not a place where individuals or corporations are able to “hide money”.

And, of course, the ritual denial that Cayman is a tax haven was delivered.

I’d have hoped that, after the excesses of the Travers years, a new Chair of Cayman Finance might have toned down the rhetoric and might even have realised the folly of tilting against windmills. But, apparently not. If McTaggart does not realise that there’s as much chance of his argument that Cayman is not a tax haven being accepted in the House of Commons, or in the UK generally, as there is of a claim from the Libyan government this morning that it is an open, liberal democracy being accepted at face value, then he very clearly does not understand first of all what a tax haven is, second what the generally accepted use of the term is and thirdly what Cayman is.

Keep issuing such absurd letters if you want Cayman, but all you prove is how far removed from reality you are, and while you do that people will rightly realise that all you have to sell is a myth – the myth that tax havens firstly do something other than let people and companies avoid their obligations to society, and secondly that doing so is useful, both of which are very obviously untrue.

When will you learn?

Share

Disclaimer: Unless specifically stated to be the views of the Task Force, the opinions expressed on this blog are solely the opinions of the individual blogger and are not necessarily those of the Task Force on Financial Integrity & Economic Development.

Latest Press Releases

GFI Calls on G8 to Tackle Illicit Financial Flows at Camp David Summit

Global Financial Integrity · May 17, 2012

WASHINGTON, DC – Global Financial Integrity (GFI) today called on leaders of the G8 to concretely tackle the issue of illicit financial ...

Civil Society, Business Groups Call on Congress to Support Incorporation Transparency, Ban Anonymous U.S. Shell Companies

FACT Coalition · May 16, 2012

WASHINGTON, DC – Today, 41 business and civil society groups sent a letter to every member of the U.S. House of Representatives ...

Glencore ‘should explain potentially corrupt deals in Congo’ – Global Witness

Global Witness · May 5, 2012

LONDON - Global Witness is today calling on Glencore to explain potentially corrupt deals in the Democratic Republic of Congo, and is ...