Task Force Blog

Blog

Aid is Nice, but Transparency is Key

June 11, 2009

By Clark Gascoigne

Clark Gascoigne is the Communications Director at Global Financial Integrity in Washington, DC.

An article in the Financial Times today uses a report from One to highlight the fact that France and Italy have not met the development goals set by the G7 at the 2005 Gleneagles Summit:

A leading development lobby group has condemned Italy and France for failing to meet targets to increase aid to sub-Saharan Africa and called on the G7 and other international organisations to take sanctions against such breaches in future…

One made the call as it published a new report assessing the progress of G7 countries in meeting targets to increase aid to Africa made at the Gleneagles Summit in 2005.

It’s certainly unfortunate that Italy and France have not met their development goals. However, even if France and Italy had met their development goals, it would not have made the necessary impact. The article states that Italy, which was donating about US$1.4 billion in aid to Sub-Saharan African countries in 2005, promised to increase their aid to just over US$5 billion; Italy has only raised their aid levels to $1.57 billion – roughly $3.5 billion short of the target. However, as GFI’s latest report points out, illicit outflows from developing countries total about $1,000 billion per year – outpacing foreign aid by a roughly 10 to 1 ratio.

Certainly keeping your word is a good thing, and Italy should not be forgiven for it, but the real problem here is the international financial structure which drains the purses of developing countries. If we really want to solve the problems in Sub-Saharan Africa, we need more than just aid – we need reform. We need transparency.

Tags: , ,

Disclaimer: Unless specifically stated to be the views of the Task Force, the opinions expressed on this blog are solely the opinions of the individual blogger and are not necessarily those of the Task Force on Financial Integrity & Economic Development.

  • http://www.gfip.org Ann Hollingshead

    I would also note that this problem is only compounded by the fact that the illicit financial flow figures for Africa are understated by a significant margin, since we have poor or missing data for many countries in that region. In fact, those African countries for which the GFI report has missing data have a cumulative GDP which accounts for nearly 37% of the region’s total GDP. Furthermore, these countries–including Zimbabwe, Somalia, Liberia, Central African Republic, and Democratic Republic of the Congo (among many others)–are likely to be hemorrhaging illicit financial flows in values disproportionate to their GDP’s, due to a lack of governance and oversight and high levels of public and private corruption.

    All in all, the problem is big. Even bigger than we’re saying.

Latest Press Releases

South Africa Joins the Task Force on Financial Integrity and Economic Development

Task Force · February 10, 2012

WASHINGTON DC – South Africa announced today that it has joined the Partnership Panel of the Task Force on Financial Integrity and ...

Global Witness: Commitments to improved transparency in the forest sector must be acted on

Global Witness · February 9, 2012

LONDON - Forest dependent communities are still in the dark about how their forests are being managed, despite additional commitments from governments ...

U.S. Senate Bill Introduced to Crack Down on Offshore Tax Abuse

Global Financial Integrity · February 7, 2012

WASHINGTON, DC – Global Financial Integrity (GFI) today applauded the introduction of a bill, which would close several major tax loopholes and ...